Six goals, a hat-trick and England's best World Cup finish since 1966 should be an unambiguous good news story, especially for coach Thomas Tuchel. 

World Cup World Cup

Instead, it doubles as the clearest evidence yet that Tuchel got his biggest selection call of the tournament wrong.

Bukayo Saka and Marcus Rashford were both left out of the XI that lost to Argentina in Wednesday's semi-final, in different ways. 

Saka never left his seat, an unused substitute in the biggest match of England's tournament.

Rashford's involvement amounted to a late cameo, and by Thierry Henry's reading on Fox Sports, one that arrived several crucial minutes too late. 

England had actually led that game, Anthony Gordon's goal putting them in front before Lionel Messi supplied two second-half assists to turn it around, Enzo Fernandez and Lautaro Martinez finishing off a 2-1 win that ended England's first realistic shot at a men's World Cup final since 1966.

Tuchel's reasoning was not invented on the spot. 

Morgan Rogers had come off the bench to help England past Norway in the quarter-final, and his manager rewarded that with a first start against Argentina, built around physicality and pace to match a side famous for slowing games to a walk. 

It was a defensible plan against the defending champions. It was also a plan that left Saka and Rashford, two players now scoring and creating at will in Miami, watching from the sidelines when England most needed a way to break a stalemate.

Bronze doesn't settle it for England or Tuchel

The two players Tuchel judged surplus to requirements against Argentina were, by full-time in Miami, the most influential players on the pitch not wearing France's number ten. Saka's hat-trick did the actual damage. 

Rashford's presence from kickoff, rather than the bench, made Henry's argument from earlier in the week look rather understated in hindsight.

None of this changes the ledger. Argentina reached the final. England did not. Tuchel's semi-final selection, built around Gordon and Rogers ahead of two players now central to England's best World Cup finish in almost sixty years, remains what it was on Wednesday night, defensible on its own terms and increasingly hard to defend against the result it produced.

The Euro 2028 question

Tuchel walked out in Miami to his own fans booing his name before kickoff. He will have left with most of them smiling, the strange gift a bronze medal match sometimes offers a manager under pressure, a fixture low enough in stakes that it lets everyone forget, for ninety-eight minutes, what was actually being adjudicated three days earlier.

It will not last. Didier Deschamps departs French football for good after this one, his 187th and final match in charge.

Tuchel does not get that clean exit. He gets two more years to work out why the players who just delivered a bronze medal weren't the ones he trusted with a place in the final.