Referee Matthew Carley has taken charge of South Africa against New Zealand three times. South Africa have won all three.

The fourth comes at Ellis Park on Saturday in the first Rugby's Greatest Rivalry Test, and the three that came before it were not remotely the same match.

There was the two-point squeeze on the Gold Coast in the 2021 Rugby Championship, 31-29. There was the 35-7 hammering at Twickenham in a World Cup warm-up two years later. And there was the arm-wrestle in Cape Town in 2024, 18-12, the only one of the three played on South African soil.

Different weather, different stakes, different sides. Same result.

New Zealand's record under Carley

New Zealand's wider record with the English official is five wins and three defeats. That sounds ordinary enough until you notice where all three defeats came from.

South Africa.

The All Blacks have beaten every other opponent Carley has refereed them against, including Australia 28-14 in the 2025 Rugby Championship, their most recent match with him in the middle.

It makes Saturday's appointment an unusual statistical footnote before a Test that needs little extra intrigue.

South Africa's own history with Carley started badly. They lost his first two Tests involving them, 22-20 to Wales in June 2018 and 30-17 to Australia in September 2021.

Since then, they have won seven in a row under him.

That run includes the two victories Carley refereed last year, a 55-10 win over Georgia in July and a 24-13 victory against Ireland in Dublin in the Quilter Nations Series.

A record, not a prediction for Rugby's Greatest Rivalry

Carley arrives at Ellis Park with 51 Tests behind him, having reached the milestone in February when Scotland beat Wales 26-23 in Cardiff.

This will be only his third Test of the year, following Scotland's 33-17 defeat of Fiji in the Nations Championship last month.

But none of that referees the match.

Officials do not win Tests, and the record of a man who has blown a whistle at nine South African games is not a prediction.

The sample is too small, and the circumstances of those matches are too different for the record to mean much beyond the curiosity it provides.

Still, it is an unusual one.

New Zealand have lost only three of the eight Tests Carley has refereed. Every one came against South Africa.

And the team responsible for all three of those defeats will be lining up opposite them again on Saturday evening.