Former Springbok captain John Smit was surprised by how readily the All Blacks tried to avoid a set-piece battle during South Africa's 3-1 series victory in Rugby's Greatest Rivalry.
Rassie Erasmus' side built the series win on a combination of scrum power, lineout accuracy, maul pressure and tactical kicking, areas in which New Zealand struggled to match the Springboks for much of the contest.
For Smit, the biggest surprise was not simply South Africa's dominance, but the extent to which the All Blacks appeared determined to reduce their exposure to the scrum and lineout.
Springboks scrum exposes All Blacks weakness
New Zealand improved at scrum time in the fourth Test, but South Africa had established a significant advantage in the earlier matches.
Smit believes the Springboks' front row, combined with the regular challenges faced by South African players in their club competitions, helped create an advantage the All Blacks struggled to counter.
“The All Blacks were surprising to me, every ball they had was channel one, they didn't want to give the Boks too many scrum feeds, which they were good at,” Smit said on the I Love Rugby podcast.
“It's a ferocious scrum and it has been building and getting better and better, and they put a lot of work into it.”
Smit pointed to Ox Nche, Malcolm Marx and Wilco Louw as a formidable combination.
“Truth be told, we've got Ox on the one side, we've got Malcolm in the middle and then we've got Wilco Louw at 140-odd kgs; you add a little bit of work and technique to that, it gets hard to stop.”
He also noticed New Zealand using quick throws towards the front of the lineout rather than engaging South Africa in a prolonged contest.
“For me the surprise was the All Blacks wanted to get away from the scrum and lineout as much as possible,” Smit said.
John Smit links issue to Super Rugby
Smit believes South Africa's move away from Super Rugby has created different development environments for the two sides.
South African players competing in the United Rugby Championship and Investec Champions Cup regularly face teams that place considerable emphasis on set-piece work, while the Super Rugby environment in Australia and New Zealand places greater emphasis on expansive attacking rugby.
“We get tested in the Investec Champions Cup against some of the best scrums, we get tested in the URC, so the scrum and the kicking game has remained of massive importance in the competitions that we're playing,” Smit said.
“Super Rugby is still such an exciting tournament to win but there's not a huge emphasis on kicking tactics and set-piece; it's more about playing the All Black way.”
Smit believes that leaves New Zealand with fewer opportunities to test its scrum against elite opposition.
“There are not a huge amount of teams that are going to really scare you from a scrum point of view and that's a difficult one to fix,” he said.
“I think the All Blacks have got the personnel but scrumming is like a UFC fighter. You can train in the gym as much as you want, but if you don't put enough time in the ring and you don't scrum every week, and you don't get tested by hard opposition, it's very difficult to understand what the level is.”
Smit does not believe South Africa's departure from Super Rugby has been as damaging to the Springboks, arguing that the move to northern-hemisphere competitions has exposed their players to a broader range of conditions and styles.
The URC and Champions Cup provide regular tests against teams prepared to compete physically up front, while varying weather, pitches and travel demands add further challenges.
“The exit for us has probably been less traumatic because we've gone over to a competition that is a little easier from a travel perspective but it's also tested us in different conditions,” Smit said.
“The seasons differ, the conditions differ, the fields differ, and we've got teams that want to engage up front and, if you don't have a kicking game and a kick receive game, you're going to come up short.”